Want to improve your model railway track work, wiring, and electrics? Soldering is the only way. But what’s the best solder to use? What’s the best soldering iron? And how can you get superior solder joints? This article will answer all your soldering questions.
The majority of the problems I come across on my model railways, and those of visitors to this blog, are down to train track connection and poor electrical contacts in the wiring.
Without a good connection, the electricity won’t flow and the trains and accessories won’t function correctly.
This is where soldering comes in.
While other techniques of joining or fixing wires — twisting them together or using a terminal block for example — may seem easier they are prone to problems. Wires fray and work loose, bare metal oxidises and twisted strands may not make a complete connection.
Soldering, by contrast, can initially seem like a lot of work but once learned is the easiest way of making reliable joints between electrical contacts — dropper wires to rails etc — and is infinitely better at passing electricity than any other option.
Soldering creates a conducting bond between the two metals being worked on and there’s no opportunity for the wires to fray or break.
Other reasons to solder include:
- Because it creates a strong, long-lasting, join,
- Because mistakes and errors can be easily corrected,
- Because solder joints are robust – rarely work loose with the vibration of trains running over rails for example.
- Because it improves the connection between the metals allowing electricity to flow better
We’ll get to how to solder in a minute but first, make sure you’ve got the best equipment.
What you’ll need: things to look for in a soldering iron, solder, and accessories
It’s a simple fact that being able to deliver the right amount of heat at the right place as quickly as possible is one of the fundamentals needed of good soldering irons.
Equally, being able to apply heat precisely so as not to damage nearby plastics — track sleepers being a case in point – is another key requirement.
Finally, the iron core should pass the heat from the heating unit to the tip consistently and quickly. A lot of cheap irons fail here, with the heat distributed unequally and taking a long time to heat the tip to the required temperature.
These features form the basis of all good irons.
You certainly don’t want to use the old clunky types probably lying around in your sheds or garage.
It took me a while to find a soldering iron that provided these but my preferred choice — and a choice echoed on many on model railway forums — is the Antex range.
And in particular, the Antex XS25 iron. I use this with a variety of tips from .5 to 1.5mil is ideal for quick jobs although for occasions when there’s a lot of track work to do this 48W temperature controlled iron is the preferred choice. The more powerful unit is needed for tracks as rails act as heat sinks and drain heat away from smaller irons faster than they can reheat.
A word of warning, there are a lot of cheaper so-called temperature controlled irons that aren’t really temperature controlled but adjust the voltage being supplied and can be slow and problematic. It took a while to find the one mentioned above that offers decent control without costing a fortune.
As yet, I’ve not had a problem with it.
The best solder
Having the best solder is just as important as having the right iron.
There’s a very good description of solder in this video. It’s a classic old-school presentation but does a great job of explaining what solder is and how it works.
The take away is that while solders may look the same, the metals used and the ratio of their mix makes a huge difference to the temperature needed to melt them, how easy they are to work with, the hardness and the quality of the joint created.
In fact, many of the problems with soldering can be traced to using the wrong solder.
So what’s the best solder?
The answer lies in the chemistry and physics and without diving into to much detail it’s down how the metals involved react to heat.
At it warms up and changes from solid to molten and then back during cooling, solder passes through an interim ‘plastic’ stage.
While in this state it doesn’t flow easily — making it harder to get it where you want it. You also don’t need to hold it against the wires or rails as long so avoiding burnt fingers — or sleepers.
Conversely, you want it to cool and solidify quickly so you can release the wires etc quickly without worrying that they will come free because the solder hasn’t completely solidified.
Additionally, while in the plastic state the surface can be disturbed by an accidental movement resulting in rough, ugly, looking joints, so the faster it transitions through this state the better.
In the video above, this is covered at time point 2:20 to 9.56.
The best solder then is one that has a low, faster to reach, melting point — so avoiding time in the plastic state while it heats up fully and cools quickly — yet one that’s still hard when set and this is down to the mix of metals used.
And I’ve found a solder mix of 63% Tin to 37% Lead is optimum to give this.
Other mixes, such as 50/50 and Tin/Lead-free, have higher melting points (e.g. they take longer to reach full melt point and take longer to cool – precisely what you don’t want) or can be too soft afterward, so creating weak joints and connections.
The 63/37 mix, however, melts very fast — and at a low 183C — and returns to its solid form just as quickly.
To this mix, I also look for a solder with a Rosin/flux-core.
The flux cleans the surface of the material being worked on to give a better joint and solder with this built-in saves having to wield the solder, iron and separate flux at the same time. (Rosin is a form of flux).
After searching, I’ve found this solder to offer the best results.
Its small diameter makes it ideal for precise work and the Tin/Lead 63/37 mix is spot on for low temperature, rapid melting/cooling.
Must-Have Soldering Accessories
An often overlooked but in my view, vital accessories for high-quality soldering is a cleaning pencil. While the flux in the solder cleans the surfaces being worked on and helps the molten solder bind, cleaning the surfaces with an abrasive cleaner will remove more dirt and oxidisation preventing a good bond and so give a much, much, better joint.
This is particularly the case with rails which attract lots of dirt and grime.
Fibreglass abrasive brushes work a treat for this (they make a good general rail cleaner too) but they do wear out quickly however so I use this one which has replaceable heads.
Oh, how my fingers would have appreciated me knowing about this when I first started.
Metal being soldered conducts not just electricity but heat and if you’ve ever tried holding a rail or wire while soldering it you’ll know the heat moves quickly and it isn’t too long before you need to let go. Invariably, this is just after the perfect joint has been made and, as you let go, the wires move before the solder has hardened wrecking the whole thing.
It was after one particularly painful finger burning experience that I started looking around for an alternative method of holding wires together and discovered the joys of crocodile clips and clamps.
The Am-Tech helping hands has been my fingers-friend ever since. It features not just clamps on adjustable arms but also a magnifying glass and soldering iron holder and is never far from reach when I’m working on my layout electrics.
A set of all metal pliers is also usually close to hand. Attaching these to wires after the point of soldering but before the signal or point motor acts as a heat sink, keeping the heat away from the delicate electronics that might otherwise be damaged. These can be found in any tool or DIY store.
Oxidisation builds upon soldering iron tips very rapidly and if not removed with frequent cleaning will contaminate the solder reducing the quality of the joint. Wire wool, or even a damp sponge, should be used to clean your soldering iron frequently.
Want To Improve Your Soldering On Your Model Railway? Here’s How.
And now the bit I promised. How to solder.
For the impatient, watch this quick video:
For those who prefer to read or print out for future reference here’s the guide Instructables which is one of my favourites on the subject as it covers not just soldering but also the often overlooked matter of cleaning.
“If you have a decent iron, the right solder and a cleaning scour you are halfway there now you just need to pay attention to a couple of important points and you will get good solder joints.
Modern soldering iron tips tend to have special coatings, this is good because it prevents the oxidising as quickly as they used to. This coating is the reason I say you should never file or sand your tip to clean it, once you start that down that route, you will probably have to keep doing it every so often and the tip will be worn out quite quickly. If you look at the tip, it will last a long time.
Now, this oxidisation happens quickly when the tip is hot, you can see it because the tip goes from shiny silver to dark and dull, it actually goes quite grey in colour and can almost become black. Now the problem is this layer of oxidation reduces heat transfer. Some people don’t realise just what an effect this has and keep trying to solder with the iron in that state. The problem is, you will struggle to make a single solder joint with a tip like that.
The secret is to clean it before every joint. Well sometimes you can do a few joints straight after each other and I would usually at least do both wires of a resistor for instance, but you can’t just keep soldering without cleaning the tip.
Now cleaning can just mean wiping the tip on your scouring pad a couple of times, so no big deal. But if the irons been sitting for a few minutes you need to go a bit further. You need to clean and then ‘tin’ the tip.
The ‘tinning’ prevents the oxidation of the tip and to do it the tip needs to be hot and clean. So you pick up your hot iron, wipe the tip on the scouring pad a few times and then immediately melt solder onto the tip to tin it. Don’t be shy with the solder, it’s cheap and it will drop off the tip as you do it, but some will stick, kind of ‘paint’ the tip with solder and then wipe the excess on your scour, then do your solder joints straight away.
If you put the iron down for a minute after tinning it, you will probably just need to wipe it on the scouring pad again and then you can solder. But wait too long and you will need to clean and tin it again. This is why it’s a good idea to load a board up with say all the resistors and then solder them all in at once instead of putting one in, solder it, put the next one in etc. That way you can do a few joints, wipe clean and do a few more etc. By the way, you should tin a new tip the first time you use it before the iron gets hot for the first time the tip will be shiny, it heats up and starts going dark, clean it and tin it.
It’s not really that difficult and with practice, it will become second nature, you will get to know when you need to tin the tip and when you can get away with just wiping it. Be careful though wiping it enough will always clean it, it should be shiny after wiping it, or it will oxidise very quickly.
Now the idea with soldering is you want to get both of the things you are joining hot enough and then introduce solder. Don’t load up the tip with solder and try to transfer it to the joint. You should touch both pieces you want to join with the tip at the same time and hold it there for a couple of seconds to allow them to heat up.
Now the best way to work out what you should be heating is to remember a simple rule: Solder will always flow towards heat.
So hold your iron on the join for a second or two, then introduce solder into the join, it will melt when it touches the iron, as soon as you see the solder flow into the joint, lift the soldering iron away. Don’t jerk it away, just lift it off.
Now to do this well you need to have everything secured in place so you can hold the iron in one hand and the solder in the other. No balancing tricks (until you know what your doing and can get away with it). This requires having everything held in place by its own weight or under tension or with a clamp, or whatever, no chasing parts around the bench with a hot iron. “
What Next To Improve Your Soldering
Products To Help:
- Basic Soldering Iron: Trusted reliable general soldering iron
- Temperature Controlled Soldering Iron, for all soldering, including track work
- Solder: Tried and trusted solder, flows easily; cools quickly for long-lasting reliable joints.
- Great Q&A guide to common soldering problems from gurus at Adafruit
- In-depth explanation of solder composition and issues around lead-free solder
- Railway Electrics: One of the most comprehensive guides to model railway electrics.
And that’s it! All I can say and recommend now is go and practice, practice, and practice but if you’ve followed these tips you shouldn’t struggle with soldering much longer.
A final, personal, note: I spend a LOT of time testing, photographing, writing and often wrecking my own layouts researching techniques for these articles and don’t charge a penny for them. If this article is useful to you or helpful, please add a comment to say so, it gives me encouragement to continue. Thanks and happy soldering, Andy.
Did you know, you can get all my latest tips, reviews and guides direct to your inbox? It's completely free. Just subscribe to my newsletter and I'll do the rest. Click here to start. Thanks Andy, creator and founder of MRE.
Disclaimer: Some links on this page will take you to Amazon or eBay through which you can buy the products mentioned. These links are made under the Amazon and eBay affiliate scheme which means that although the price to you doesn't change I get a small commission on the orders you place. Please see the disclaimer for more details.