How NOT to clean track, part 2

how not to clean model railway track 2Cleaning track is a fundamental maintenance task on a model railway but it’s surprising how badly wrong it can go.

As I covered in part 1 in how not to clean your track, there some chemicals you should never use on your railway track. But cleaning fluids aren’t the only thing some people get wrong. Catastrophic errors can also be made by using the wrong tools.

A case in point is a Dremel. Like WD-40 in the last post.

For the right kind of job a Dremel is hard to beat and one should be in every modeller’s toolbox but never fit one out with a sanding disc for track cleaning.  There’s a great discussion here covering the story of one hobbyist mistakenly using a Dremel in this way to clean their track.

But the worst mistake I’ve seen in track cleaning was a few years back.

This really happened.

An acquaintance had inherited a large quantity of old OO gauge track that needed a lot of TLC.  Unfortunately, the technique this DIY fanatic choose was anything but tender.

The track had been found in a dark, spider-infested, shed and having been left there unprotected for some time had rusted.

Not understanding the mechanics of rails or how delicate they are but faced with long stretches of metal to clean Paul went to work with DIY power sander.

Yep, a sander!

His rationale being that sandpaper would shift the crap off the rails and a sander would speed to job up saving himself hours of work.

Sadly, by the time he called me it was too late.

At best, his railheads were scored and scratched and in some places had even been sanded away leaving nasty drops in track height. After a quick inspection, I had to tell him to throw out the majority of the track!

He wasn’t happy!

What he should have done

Hopefully, no one reading this will make the same mistake but I do hear of other sad sandpaper exploits. Save yourself the frustration and never let sandpaper near your rails. It’ll scratch the metal making dust and dirt far harder to clean in future.

Instead, click on any of the following and take a look at

for practical advice on keeping your track clean, the safe way.



PS, If you liked this, join over 23,000 model railway fans and sign up now to get my unique guides and tips. It's completely free, you can unsubscribe at any time and I promise to never spam you.
 
"Awesome stuff. I will be using your site a lot, for tips and ideas." @MuddingtonIII
 
Click here to get more free tips

6 comments
  1. Appreciate your thoughts on track cleaning. But, what DO you recommend for a cleaning solution ? I have purchased (sight unseen) track in bulk and it has red acrylic paint along the area.where the rail and track mount meet– (Bachman EZ track) I was told mineral sprits may do the trick but I think that would leave an oily film on rails. Any suggestions?

    • Michael, If you have paint on the railheads run a block of wood over them a few times. Being wood this won’t scratch or damage the rails (as some abrasive blocks do) but will still rub away the paint. After this, a quick application of IPA will remove dirt etc left behind. It’s simple to use, give it a go here. Andy

  2. Andy, the block of wood sounds like it might do the trick for the rail heads but my problem is where the track and the plastic base meet.(Bachman EZ Track).
    There is a red substance on a lot of the track that I was told may be acrylic paint.
    But I also find this same red on parts from Bachman that are in areas that would normally never have paint of any kind. ( IE-switch joints) And yes, I will write to Bachman but was wondering if you know about this as well as a cure.
    Thanks—–

    • Hi Michael, hmmm. I can understand your frustration. I’m not aware of any easy way of getting into those areas to clean them. I’ve had to do this before and ended up scraping the paint out with a cocktail stick (slow work!). Have you considered painting over them with a rail coloured paint? Andy

  3. If your cleaning block has shiny things in them, use it to polish anything but the rails. Why? Take your “bright” block and cross-rub your rails on a piece of scrap track, that is, the same direction of the ties/sleepers. It will show you a “cross-grain” set of scratches. These scratches are not as noticeable when rubbing parallel to the rails. They are scratched! I use most any paper fiber product to clean my rails. A light application of certain lip-balm then gets applied. And a quick check at frogs and certain wheels that picked up any gunk from hard to reach areas is next. I rarely have to clean my track.

Add Comment

Required fields are marked *. Your email address will not be published.

19 + ten =